Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Steve Prefontaine Over or Under Rated?

Collapse

Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
    Guest
    Guest

  • Guest's Avatar
    Guest replied
    Re: Steve Prefontaine Over or Under Rated?

    Pre was a tough guy. He was novel in that not many Americans ever challenge at the very top of the distance running scene. He spoke his mind. The 'rebel' image is something that Americans enjoy in many sports etc.

    He wouldn't have won the 5k in '76. He probably wouldn't even have medaled. I think he would have gotten the silver in the 10k if had been around. The guys in the 5k were better, faster runners than Pre at the shorter distance.

    Leave a comment:

  • Guest
    Guest

  • Guest's Avatar
    Guest replied
    Re: Steve Prefontaine Over or Under Rated?

    >He's perhaps mildly overrated in a domestic sense
    >and definitely overrated in an international
    >sense. Does the name Ian Stewart ring a bell? You
    >may recall that he was the one whose late charge
    >beat out Pre for bronze in Munich. They were born
    >2 years and 10 days apart (Stewart older). Pre
    >fanatics love to think of him as this incredible
    >prodigy. He was damned good, but....

    Here are
    >their 5K world rankings at the same
    >age:

    20--Stewart 3, Pre 10
    21--Stewart 1, Pre
    >4
    22--Stewart 3, Pre 5

    Does anybody think of
    >Stewart as one of the all-time greats? I think
    >not, but he was certainly more of a "prodigy"
    >than Pre was and fared far better on the
    >itnernational stage.

    And if you'd like to cite
    >for me what a tough little bastard Pre was, note
    >that Stewart took up running so that he could get
    >into the British Special Forces and his career
    >was interrupted by minor trifles such as serving
    >in Viet Nam and sitting for weeks in the belly of
    >a submarine submerged off the Arctic coast of a
    >hostile Soviet Union. Talk about under-rated
    >guys!

    Garry - very curious if anything akin to that has been published in T&FN. ... just curious.

    Leave a comment:

  • pickle47
    Senior Member

  • pickle47
    replied
    Re: Steve Prefontaine Over or Under Rated?

    Again, as a distance runner who came of age during Pre's years, he was something of a hero to me also. Depending on your personality at the time, you would find yourself identifying with either him or Frank Shorter. Although there were other good American runners, those two sort of carried the American torch for the 3K to 10K distances.
    Was he among the best in the world? Absolutely. The best? Of course not. And I've already said on another thread that he wouldn't have beaten Viren.

    I don't think Pre had refined his tactics to the level necessary to beat racers with better kicks that possessed the same or better fitness than he did. Recall that Brendan Foster started using mid-race surges effectively in 1974 and 75, but Carlos Lopes employed a more gradual acceleration from the front in the '76 10K and Foster couldn't handle that strategy.

    It probably would have taken something as radical as John Ngugi's mid-race surge in the Seoul 5K (when have we seen a race like that since then??!!) to win the '76 race, and I don't think Pre or anyone else had the goods at that time.

    Leave a comment:

  • Guest
    Guest

  • Guest's Avatar
    Guest replied
    Re: Steve Prefontaine Over or Under Rated?

    I was rather young when he passed on, but I have nothing but positive memories of Pre. He was a credit to the sport, and he left a standard for up and comers to go by.

    Leave a comment:

  • gh
    Administrator

  • gh
    replied
    Re: Steve Prefontaine Over or Under Rated?

    He's perhaps mildly overrated in a domestic sense and definitely overrated in an international sense. Does the name Ian Stewart ring a bell? You may recall that he was the one whose late charge beat out Pre for bronze in Munich. They were born 2 years and 10 days apart (Stewart older). Pre fanatics love to think of him as this incredible prodigy. He was damned good, but....

    Here are their 5K world rankings at the same age:

    20--Stewart 3, Pre 10
    21--Stewart 1, Pre 4
    22--Stewart 3, Pre 5

    Does anybody think of Stewart as one of the all-time greats? I think not, but he was certainly more of a "prodigy" than Pre was and fared far better on the itnernational stage.

    And if you'd like to cite for me what a tough little bastard Pre was, note that Stewart took up running so that he could get into the British Special Forces and his career was interrupted by minor trifles such as serving in Viet Nam and sitting for weeks in the belly of a submarine submerged off the Arctic coast of a hostile Soviet Union. Talk about under-rated guys!

    Leave a comment:

  • Guest
    Guest

  • Guest's Avatar
    Guest replied
    Re: Steve Prefontaine Over or Under Rated?

    Upper echelon on world scene ... but unproven.

    Viren owned 5 and 10k Olys - no way Pre (or anyone else) wins 76

    ANY chance of breaking into medals would be if he 'goes' with 6, maybe 7 laps to go ... AFTER an honest pace the first part of race. No walking in that company. That was my contention then (before Munich), my story now and I'm stickin to it. I never believed he could win waitin til last mile.

    Over-under-rated: deification by subsequent generations over the top. He did revolutionize the sport in USA - and not many with his moxy. Throw em down, see who's left.

    Leave a comment:

  • Guest
    Guest

  • Guest's Avatar
    Guest replied
    Re: Steve Prefontaine Over or Under Rated?

    I don't think he was overrated. He was up there with the best 5000 runners of his time, and that is certainly a big accomplishment.

    However, I don't think he would have beaten Viren in 1976.

    Leave a comment:

  • The King
    Senior Member

  • The King
    replied
    Re: Steve Prefontaine Over or Under Rated?

    I think he would of won the 1976 OG Men's 5000m final.

    As for either over-rated or under-rated..
    I don't know...

    Leave a comment:

  • Guest
    Guest

  • Guest's Avatar
    Guest started a topic Steve Prefontaine Over or Under Rated?

    Steve Prefontaine Over or Under Rated?

    What do you think of him???
    Would he have won the gold in 76?
Working...
X