2021 College Football

[jazzcyclist Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close jazzcyclist]

Normally I would wait until the preseason rankings come out before I start this thread but with so much news being made off the field with the new NIL rules and conference realignment, I figured now is as good a time as any. I guess it's only fitting that Texas and Oklahoma would be the first dominoes to fall in the "Wild, Wild West Era of College Football". Here are a few questions?

1. Will there be any policing of the NIL rules or will the schools with the richest and most enthusiastic boosters hoard all the best athletes?
2. Will schools use the NIL rules to entice football players to exhaust their eligibility?
3. Will Notre Dame remain independent?
4. Will the ACC and Pac 12 come out of this year unscathed?
5. Vanderbilt is obviously the answer to the "Which one of these things is not like the others" song. Will the SEC ever give them the boot?

[gm Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close gm]

Football is the least affected by this, but an interesting conundrum anyway -- foreign athletes could lose their visas if they earn money through NIL?

https://www.espn.com/college-sports/...m-seems-answer

[KevinR Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close KevinR]

For basketball, and to a lesser extent football and baseball, I expect the NIL change to keep those athletes who will not expect the big signing bonuses from risking going early. In basketball, if you are at best a second rounder, you can probably make more money by staying in college and making money there, while getting a lot of playing time and dedicated coaching. Now a lot of those guys go G League or overseas, but the G League may not pay as well, and few guys start out overseas and ever make it back to the NBA.

I do not know of any reason that the "boosters" will not take a very active role in keeping kids in school, or enticing them to attend particular schools. We all hear about the kid at a D1 school who gets a new "loaner" car to drive around campus while his own car is in the shop......for years. In the future, he will just be able to endorse the dealership on a commercial, and take the cash outright.

[scottmitchell74 Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close scottmitchell74]

I wonder in the long term how much money will really be made by the non-star athletes. Yes, the absolute stars will make quite a bit, but after the initial excitement I wonder about the "regular" athletes.

[Bruce Kritzler Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Bruce Kritzler]

Football is the least affected by this, but an interesting conundrum anyway -- foreign athletes could lose their visas if they earn money through NIL?
https://www.espn.com/college-sports/...m-seems-answer

That's funny, because many foreign collegians have already received compensation from their clubs/associations.

[Atticus Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Atticus]

How long before a huge scandal breaks when they find out boosters are paying big bucks for NIL merchandising.

[Helen S Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Helen S]

I wonder in the long term how much money will really be made by the non-star athletes. Yes, the absolute stars will make quite a bit, but after the initial excitement I wonder about the "regular" athletes.

you mean most of them- including D2 and D3, most of D1, both men and women.

[KevinR Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close KevinR]

How long before a huge scandal breaks when they find out boosters are paying big bucks for NIL merchandising.

I am not sure that would be a scandal, under these guidelines. It seems like a logical transition.

[Atticus Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Atticus]

I am not sure that would be a scandal, under these guidelines. It seems like a logical transition.

Then the rich will simply get richer and they'll ensure they not only get the very best, but that the very best will stay till eligibility runs out. There i$ much more intere$t in college teams being good than the pro$. Boosters will pay BIG to brag.

[Conor Dary Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Conor Dary]

That's funny, because many foreign collegians have already received compensation from their clubs/associations.

Really...like who....the Brits running in the US I am aware of haven't seen a pence from the UK.

[steve Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close steve]

Then the rich will simply get richer and they'll ensure they not only get the very best, but that the very best will stay till eligibility runs out. There i$ much more intere$t in college teams being good than the pro$. Boosters will pay BIG to brag.

I don't know that the best will make more from staying in college, but if they do stay they would have to be enrolled and school, so on the positive side maybe more of them would graduate. As KevinR mentioned, I would also guess that a lot of the athletes staying would be those drafted in 2nd or greater rounds, and hoping to get more development at the college level while still able to get something by marketing themselves.

As far as the rich getting richer it seems like that's already happening with Alabama, Ohio State, and Clemson without this system. Since many of their guys will still be good enough to leave early and get the enormous signing bonuses, this might be a way to break their stranglehold on the BCS with the remaining schools getting better player development.

[NotDutra5 Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close NotDutra5]

How long before a huge scandal breaks when they find out boosters are paying big bucks for NIL merchandising.

Is this against the rules?

[DrJay Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close DrJay]

Will there be some sort of “fair market value” for NIL? If not, some mega wealthy donor could simply buy an 8 x 10 color glossy of the Alabama quarterback for $5 million and there you go, the kid is $5 million richer.

[jazzcyclist Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close jazzcyclist]

Will there be some sort of “fair market value” for NIL? If not, some mega wealthy donor could simply buy an 8 x 10 color glossy of the Alabama quarterback for $5 million and there you go, the kid is $5 million richer.

As I was saying, the Wild West era has begun. An Alabama recruit has already signed deals worth more than a million dollars before he even set a foot on campus.

[gm Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close gm]

That's funny, because many foreign collegians have already received compensation from their clubs/associations.

Not the same I don't think, since it isn't being earned here.